IPP Software Navigation Tools IPP Links Communication Pan-STARRS Links

Changes between Version 37 and Version 38 of ppSub_testing_201201


Ignore:
Timestamp:
Feb 13, 2012, 1:44:55 PM (14 years ago)
Author:
Mark Huber
Comment:

--

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • ppSub_testing_201201

    v37 v38  
    88 * has something changed in the data or what the code is doing
    99
    10 General tasks (no particular order):
     10General tasks (no particular order and by no means complete):
    1111 * need to establish a baseline to verify against any past/future changes in code and with reprocessing including a test set of real+simulated images that is '''readily''' inter-comparable (avoid having to pull values from logfiles etc)
    1212  * IPP/ppSub: current ops tag ipp-20111222, branches/meh_branches/ppsub_test [available]
    1313  * photpipe/HOTPANTS: V3 configuration locally configured [in progress, HOTPANTS compiled on all machines]
    1414  * datasets:
    15    * MD04: for S-S and S-refstk (may want W-refstk later) [in progress, image selection with some known events finished but need to "bundle"]
    16    * sim: for all cases W-W, W-S, S-S, S-refstk [in progress, mostly created from past testing with ppStack]
    17    * 3PI/other:  for W-W and W-S cases [still need to select images to use]
    18  * wrap up test and activate the convolution direction choice in ppSub for a general use option
    19   * does it still work as it did when tested a few months ago with MD10.V2? [to test for the baseline sample MD04.V3, sim, 3PI/other(?)]
    20   * if it chooses to convolved the input nightly stack, is it poorer (see recent monitoring)
    21  * test and verify the PSF matching and convolution
    22   *
    23   * the "no-conv" choice - what prevents the
    24  * investigate options for the false detections
    25   * flags2 use, may be solved with PSF matching or convolution direction
    26   * DIFF_* diffim stats
    27 
    28  * monitor if working as expected and address any additional issues found
    29   *
     15   * MD04: for S-S and S-refstk (may want W-refstk later) [in progress, image selection with some known events finished but need to "bundle" and push into photpipe]
     16   * sim: for all cases W-W, W-S, S-S, S-refstk [in progress, mostly created from past testing with ppStack but again "bundle"]
     17   * 3PI/other:  for W-W and W-S cases [still need to select images to use, then "bundle"]
     18 * wrap up and re-test the convolution direction choice in ppSub (see monitor)
     19  * does it still work as it did when tested a few months ago with MD10.V2? [to test for the baseline sample MD04.V3 S-refstk and S-S, sim, 3PI/other(?)]
     20  * if it chooses to convolved the input, is it poorer (see recent monitoring)
     21 * verify the PSF matching, convolution and diffims - test as expected, self-comparison, cross-comparison (will need translation map for different outputs)
     22  * PSF shape - is it equivalent to the target before convolution and subtraction (is there a scaling/normalization issue?)
     23  * forced photometry measurements on sky and selected sources (stats and residuals)
     24  * return to stamp choices - need a check for "poor" not being rejected
     25  * the "no-conv" case - what is limiting ppSub - have many cases of "close" inputs, what are the resulting kernels and output convolution params
     26 * sources of "extra" false diffim detections
     27  * start using of flags2 and DIFF_* diffim stats - need to map conditions in more detail (see tuning)
     28 * monitor new data/reprocessing/tag changes
     29  * initially new data as MD04 is ongoing and IQ is improved - convolution direction tests, false detection tests
     30  * obviously test changes with ppsub_test
    3031 * parameter space/tuning
    31   * kernels (current ppSub using equivalent HOTPANTS, pandromeda pipeline values) and proper scaling.
    32   *
     32  * kernels (current ppSub using equivalent HOTPANTS, pandromeda pipeline values) and proper scaling -- currently ppSub actually seems mostly insensitive to the kernel params
     33  * DIFF_xRATIO diffim stats (photpipe vs MT)
     34
    3335
    3436== Background ==
     
    5254
    5355Branch for originally testing the choice of convolution direction but now full development testing is also updated to r33098 (from 1/11/2012) -- http://svn.pan-starrs.ifa.hawaii.edu/trac/ipp/browser/branches/meh_branches/ppsub_test
     56Summary of changes so far:
    5457 * for convolution direction choice
    5558  * normalization updated each direction -- need to look if in path for ppStack fixed, seem to recall modifies even fixed (may be for both)
    56  * for both 
     59 * for both?
    5760  * kernel scaling based on Kron radius instead of
    5861 * general, help for MOPS using DIFF_R_P for cuts