Changes between Initial Version and Version 1 of MOPS_IASC20130319_tests130422

Timestamp:

Jun 6, 2013, 10:49:22 AM (13 years ago)

Author:

Mark Huber

Comment:

--

MOPS_IASC20130319_tests130422

@@ +1 @@
+= Summary of MOPS_IASC20130319_tests130422 =
+[[PageOutline]]
+
+Comparison of MOPS diffim discoveries to IASC visual chip inspection for OSS.20130319
+
+Related summary pages:
+ * [wiki:MD_WSdiffim_photcheck_test20121004]
+ * [wiki: ppSub_testing_201201]
+ * [wiki:MOPS_diff_false_positives] 
+ * 
+
+
+MOPS/IASC sample exposures to compare to (162.OSS.O.Q.w ps1_14_2124 visit 1-4, quad):
+{{{
+| exp_id | exp_name    | dateobs             | comment                           |
++--------+-------------+---------------------+-----------------------------------+
+| 590994 | o6370g0351o | 2013-03-19 11:37:26 | 162.OSS.O.Q.w ps1_14_2124 visit 1 | 
+| 591016 | o6370g0373o | 2013-03-19 11:59:29 | 162.OSS.O.Q.w ps1_14_2124 visit 2 | 
+| 591038 | o6370g0395o | 2013-03-19 12:21:39 | 162.OSS.O.Q.w ps1_14_2124 visit 3 | 
+| 591060 | o6370g0417o | 2013-03-19 12:43:52 | 162.OSS.O.Q.w ps1_14_2124 visit 4 |
+}}}
+
+
+__need to add related warp_id, diff_id table__
+
+
+Related MOPS czar pages: http://mopshq2.ifa.hawaii.edu/czar/psmops_ps1_mdrm152/tracklets.html?sort=d&limit=100&nn=56369&minv=0.1&sm=162.OSS.O&run_id=831
+
+
+Datastore products:
+{{{
+pub.791526.diff.406579  2013-03-19T14:01:22Z    IPP-MOPS        162.OSS.O.Q.w ps1_14_2124 visit 1       o6370g0351o     o6370g0373o
+pub.791568.diff.406688  2013-03-19T15:17:53Z    IPP-MOPS        162.OSS.O.Q.w ps1_14_2124 visit 3       o6370g0395o     o6370g0417o
+
+3330813323.gpc1_IPP-MOPS-TEST_IPP-MOPS-TEST.791526.pos.mops
+3330814731.gpc1_IPP-MOPS-TEST_IPP-MOPS-TEST.791526.neg.mops
+
+3331155060.gpc1_IPP-MOPS-TEST_IPP-MOPS-TEST.791568.pos.mops
+3331158431.gpc1_IPP-MOPS-TEST_IPP-MOPS-TEST.791568.neg.mops
+}}}
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+= MOPS to IASC object comparison = 
+
+Missed IASC objects within ~2" in the diffims: ~30% !!
+{{{
+o6370g0351o     o6370g0373o
+3330813323.gpc1_IPP-MOPS-TEST_IPP-MOPS-TEST.791526.pos.mops = 147/514
+3330814731.gpc1_IPP-MOPS-TEST_IPP-MOPS-TEST.791526.neg.mops = 168/523
+
+o6370g0395o     o6370g0417o
+3331155060.gpc1_IPP-MOPS-TEST_IPP-MOPS-TEST.791568.pos.mops = 170/519
+3331158431.gpc1_IPP-MOPS-TEST_IPP-MOPS-TEST.791568.neg.mops = 169/505
+}}}
+
+
+''Need MOPS diffim object list to reverse compare..''
+
+
+
+
+== IASC Objects Missed in Diffims (Manual Inspection) ==
+Cases for missing matches:
+ * (s/n) S/N too low for detection (will need additional match to SMF for photerr measurement)
+ * edge or masked -- really two cases
+  * (edge) edges and masks have growth factor from convolution
+  * (mask) non-target image has mask so diffim has mask (why WS diffim should be better in addition to S/N)
+
+|| Object || diffim || mode || skycell || ra dec || comment ||
+||  ||  ||  ||  ||  ||
+|| TVPS480 || 791526.pos || 1 || 1278.021 || 185.470925  -3.000194 || not visual in diffim, smudge in warp. SMF detect? ||
+|| K11UO3A || 791526.pos || 1 || 1279.019 || 186.089088  -3.404686 || cell edge and mask ||
+||  ||  ||  ||  ||  ||
+
+
+
+= Re-run tests = 
+
+== diffim stats ==
+For full OSS.20130319 diffim exposure/skycell sample:
+ * convolve input = 1393
+ * convolve template/reference/input 2 = 968
+ * dual convolution = 179
+{{{
+-- need cam stage stat summary
+      Input FWHM: 4.949776
+      Reference FWHM: 5.265106
+}}}
+
+Only IASC exposures:
+ * convolve input = 
+ * convolve template/reference/input 2 = 
+ * dual convolution = 
+
+
+reruns with dual convolution and no-dual convolution (issue is typically no-dual case has different kernel params)
+
+
+